Typography and intellectual property: how do we protect what we draw?

Article by Olivier Gourvat

We can spend months, sometimes years, designing a type family. We invest our time, our energy, and occasionally a few nights’ sleep. We watch it grow and refine every detail: it becomes something of our baby. The upside, if we insist on finding one, is that people like our typeface. It is a form of recognition we could have done without.

A typeface often begins with just a few letters. An intention, a proportion, a particular way of shaping a curve. Then come hundreds of decisions: balancing forms, developing weights, drawing italics, adjusting spacing, and expanding character sets.

For an independent foundry, this work represents a considerable artistic, technical, and financial investment. It can continue for years through updates and language extensions. Once the fonts are released, another task begins: enforcing their terms of use and defending the rights attached to them. It is an aspect of the profession we are rarely as well prepared for as we are for drawing.

But how do we establish our rights and protect this work? After obtaining a registration certificate from the EUIPO covering the European Union, I wanted to share my experience and consider the tools available to foundries today to defend their type designs.

When you are asked to prove your rights

Over the years, some companies have asked me to provide official documents establishing my rights to a typeface. Sometimes to support a claim, sometimes to verify the legitimacy of my approach. The situation can seem paradoxical: you designed the characters, kept the working files, published the specimens, and brought the typeface to market. Yet the person you are dealing with wants an immediately recognisable official document.

I have also encountered stranger situations in which competing foundries were commercially exploiting the name of one of my typefaces for search engine optimisation. I find this a highly questionable practice on the part of fellow professionals whose names I will not mention. Using the reputation of someone else’s work to attract a few additional customers seems far removed from the respect we should have for one another’s creations.

These experiences led me to look for ways to better document and defend my work. Above all, they prompted me to clarify a question we often frame too broadly: when we talk about “protecting a font,” what exactly are we trying to protect?

“Font is a software”: an essential dimension

In our profession, the phrase “font is a software” comes up regularly. It reminds us that a digital font is more than a collection of drawings. An OpenType file also contains data governing how those drawings are used: character-to-glyph mappings, positioning, substitutions, ligatures, and contextual forms. Some fonts also contain hinting instructions. A significant part of our work involves building and testing this behaviour, particularly for complex writing systems.

This raises the question of protection under software copyright. In the European Union, computer programs may qualify for copyright protection when they constitute their author’s own intellectual creation. This protection covers the expression of the program; it does not grant exclusive rights over ideas, principles, or functionality as such. Whether something qualifies as software, and whether it meets the requirements for protection, must therefore be assessed: an .otf or .ttf extension alone is not enough to establish either.

We therefore need to distinguish the forms we draw from their implementation in a digital font. Copying a file, reusing its code, or redrawing similar-looking characters may require different analyses.

This distinction explains why a design registration does not cover every aspect of a font. The European design system includes typographic typefaces among the products eligible for protection, while excluding computer programs from that definition. Here, registration protects the appearance represented in the application; any protection of the software falls under a different legal framework.

The end-user licence agreement, or EULA, sets out the permissions granted: installation, web use, embedding in an application, or sharing with service providers, depending on the terms offered. It governs the contractual relationship without replacing intellectual property rights.

“Font is software” therefore expresses an important reality of our profession. It does not, on its own, encompass the whole of type design or its protection.

Piracy: choosing where to focus your energy

Like many type designers, I have found a large number of my fonts offered without permission on download websites. With a little irony, we could almost take it as a compliment: they seem to be appreciated enough for some people to want to use them without buying them. Behind the joke, the reality remains discouraging. The file circulates easily; the work that made it possible becomes invisible.

One initial step is to ask Google to remove the relevant search results on copyright grounds, notably through the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, or DMCA. When a request is accepted, the reported links may be removed from search results. This is a positive first outcome, but a limited one: it does not remove the pages or files from the website hosting them, nor does it mean the entire website will disappear from search results.

These requests can reduce the visibility of some copies. However, they take time, and new URLs appear while you are dealing with the previous ones. For a small business, pursuing every illegal website can become a full-time job. That is also time we are no longer spending on design.

Focusing your strategy on actual use

With experience, I have therefore shifted part of my strategy towards the end use of my typefaces, particularly professional and commercial use.

When a company uses a font on its website, in its application, or in its communications, the practical question becomes whether it has permission and whether its licence covers that use.

Naturally, the facts need to be checked before making any claim. A visible use does not demonstrate the absence of a licence. One may have been purchased through a distributor, by an agency, or as part of a subscription. The aim is to identify genuinely unauthorised uses and then seek to bring them into compliance through an identifiable contact.

I often find this approach more useful than endlessly pursuing download websites. It allows us to focus our resources on situations where our work is being used and where a conversation can lead to a resolution.

My journey to the EUIPO

These difficulties also prompted me to seek an official registered right covering my type designs.

In France, I found the process of working with the INPI difficult to navigate, even with a lawyer’s assistance. In my case, the route did not seem clear enough for the particular nature of our profession. This is my personal experience: French law does provide for the protection of typefaces through design rights. The difficulty I encountered lay in putting that process into practice. My research then led me to the EUIPO, the European Union Intellectual Property Office.

The EU design registration symbol, indicating protection of a design’s appearance, including typographic letterforms.
The EU design registration symbol, indicating protection of a design’s appearance, including typographic letterforms.


I discovered that the international Locarno Classification includes a subclass specifically dedicated to type and typefaces: 18-03, which includes printing type and alphabets. This classification organises applications; it does not, by itself, guarantee their validity.

I prepared specimen sheets showing the characters and their use in text settings. Shortly afterwards, I received the official registration certificate. This reflects my experience, rather than a processing time guaranteed by the Office.


What design registration offers

A registered European Union design protects the appearance of a creation across all 27 Member States. Its initial term is five years from the filing date, renewable up to a total of twenty-five years. This coverage applies to the European Union, rather than every country on the European continent.

For a typeface, preparing the representations requires particular care. Protection covers the features of appearance visible in the application, so it is important to think precisely about the forms and styles you want to cover.

It is also important to understand what the certificate establishes. During registration, the EUIPO does not examine the design’s novelty or individual character. A registration may subsequently be challenged and declared invalid if the requirements for protection are not met. The document therefore confirms a registration. It does not definitively resolve every question concerning validity, ownership, or infringement.

Timing matters as much as filing

For a foundry with an established back catalogue, this point is essential. The European system provides a twelve-month grace period for certain disclosures made by the designer or their successor in title. Beyond that period, an earlier publication may undermine the design’s novelty and lead to its registration being declared invalid.

It would therefore be misleading to present registration as a way of retroactively protecting every form in a family that has been commercially available for several years. An update does not automatically reset the clock for the entire family. The specific designs, the elements already made public, and the relevant dates all need to be examined.

Protecting the family name too

A typeface’s name can acquire considerable value. Over the years, it brings together a reputation, examples of use, recommendations, and all the communication work carried out around the family.

Registering the design does not automatically protect that name as a trade mark. Two separate EUIPO applications can therefore complement one another:

  • An EU design application, covering the type designs represented in the filing.
  • A European Union trade mark application, or EUTM, submitted through the EUTM Filing form, covering the name used to distinguish the relevant goods or services.

Both procedures are available through the EUIPO’s online services. Once the registrations have been obtained, they provide official titles identifying their owner and what has been registered. When dealing with another party, this allows you to provide precise references: a number, a date, an owner, and registered subject matter.

These registrations do not, however, provide an absolute guarantee covering the entire family. Their scope depends, among other things, on the designs represented, the goods and services specified, the requirements for validity, and earlier rights. Filing a trade mark application does not guarantee registration either.

Global Fonts, territorial protection

Our fonts circulate around the world, but the rules protecting them are not identical in the United States, the European Union, or other countries. Protection of the design, its software implementation, and its name may be governed by different rules. International conventions establish a common foundation without making every system equivalent. The phrase “font is software” must therefore also be understood within the relevant legal context.

The United Kingdom provides a practical example of this territorial dimension. A trade mark can protect a family’s name for the specified goods and services. Since Brexit, a new European Union trade mark no longer covers the United Kingdom: separate UK protection is required if you also want to protect that name there.

Unfortunately, there is no magic formula. A strategy needs to take account of the markets in which we operate, the rights available, and the resources we can devote to enforcing them. For an independent foundry, that means choosing priorities.

What about french designers?

Why pursue these registrations when copyright protection is already available in France? ATypI, the Association Typographique Internationale, has long campaigned for the protection of type designs, contributing notably to the work that led to the Vienna Agreement of 1973. However, that agreement never entered into force, despite being ratified by France.

In France, the law of 3 July 1985 explicitly added “graphic and typographic works” to the works covered by copyright, wording now found in Article L112-2 of the French Intellectual Property Code. An original typographic creation can therefore benefit from copyright protection without registration.

But this protection does not remove the need to prepare your case: in a dispute, you must be able to establish your rights and explain the originality of your creation. Source files, development stages, and agreements with collaborators are therefore valuable. European registrations can complement this protection, with each system subject to its own requirements.

Making protection part of foundry practice

This experience has convinced me that protection is worth making part of our working habits. Keeping source files and their versions, of course. Documenting contributions. Preserving records of first publications. Clarifying licences. Considering registration options before release. Building a file when a problematic use comes to light. These steps take time, but reconstructing the evidence several years later is much harder.

We also need to accept that our resources are limited. We cannot pursue every copy, monitor every website, or take legal action in every case. A useful strategy needs to acknowledge that reality and allow us to keep creating.

I am sharing this experience because I would have appreciated a practical account from another type designer earlier in my career. We readily discuss the design of our typefaces on social media. We should be able to speak just as openly about how we document and defend our creations.

We take the time to draw our typefaces. Let us also make time for the work that will help us defend them !

Share this article

X Twitter
LinkedIn
Facebook
Email